Agree to Disagree vol.7 : Ranking the 2018 OT Class

By Chris Smith
Apr. 22, 2018

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports
Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

The draft is now just a few days away, suspense is building and Agree to Disagree is back with Positional Rankings, next up is the .

This week rabid Eagles fan, NFL savant, and official co-host of Agree to Disagree, Justin Polasek joins us.


1) Mike Mcglinchey

Easily the most complete tackle in this class, though I'd hesitate to call this a great year for Tackles. Great Size at 6-7 309 and a frame that could add 15 pounds. Solid technically in both run and pass blocking situations, although hes better as a run blocker. Lacks awareness at times when pass blocking, but has shown the ability to handle elite pass rushers such as Harold Landry.

2) Connor William's

William's is probably the best technician in this class, and is an above average athlete at the position. However he seemingly regressed last season, is widely considered too weak for the position. But I'm gonna bet on his exceptional work ethic to make the necessary improvements be be a fine tackle at the next level.

3) Orlando Brown

Orlando Brown is currently a laughingstock due to one of worst NFL combine performances in history. But if you really watch the tape you see a player who is a true mountain of a man that plays faster and stronger than his combine numbers indicate.

4) Kolton Miller

This is more of potential vs production. Miller had many mental lapses, and inconsistencies in protection at UCLA last season. But hes more than big enough for the position, and is an above average athlete, so he more than likely will be slightly overdrafted. His production in the NFL will be almost entirely situationally dependent

5) Brian O'Neil

Similar to Miller this is more about potential than production. O'Neil is smaller than Miller, but he is a fantastic athlete, but is very inconsistent in technique.

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports
Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports


1. Mike McGlinchey, Notre Dame

Mike is a guy who is came up in a family that absolutely radiates football. He loves the sport and plays the tackle position artistically. He's a very technically sound, smart, and instinctive player with good athleticism. At 6'8" 312, he needs to add a little more muscle to handle powerful bull rushers, but he will be a very good tackle in the NFL.

2. Connor Williams, Texas

At 6'5" Connor isn't quite as tall as some of these other guys, but he has been a very good tackle for Texas since his freshman year, fell off a little bit in 2017, but if he can regain his 2016 form, he may be the top tackle in this draft, if he can't, he may need to move inside to Gaurd or Center in the NFL. He has elite hand usage and an aggressive play style.

3. Orlando Brown, Oklahoma

Orlando Brown had a famously bad combine, but don't let that fool you. He may not be the most athletic guy, but the man can play. When you turn on the tape, you'll see a man who has an absolutely massive frame at 6'8" 360 pounds, and knows how to use it. He has heavy hands and can absolutely maul incoming rushers.

4. Kolton Miller, UCLA

Kolton's draft stock has been sky rocketing lately. He's got a lot of potential, but still has a ways to go before becoming a starter in the NFL. With his athleticism at 6'9" 310 pounds, there's a whole lot to like. He needs better technique, but he has a motor that never stops and a willingness to learn. He could become a very good starter in the NFL if he goes to a good coach.

5. Tyrell Crosby, Oregon

Crosby is a powerful mauler whose aggressive play style will make him an NFL starter. He may not have the athleticism to be a Tackle, so he may need to go to Gaurd, but either way, he will be a starter in the NFL. He thrives in the run game and can really move people.