Agree to Disagree vol.11 : Ranking the 2018 LB Class

By Chris Smith
Apr. 25, 2018

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports
Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

The draft is now just a few days away, suspense is building and Agree to Disagree is back with Positional Rankings, next up is the Linebackers.

This week rabid Eagles fan, NFL savant, and official co-host of Agree to Disagree, Justin Polasek joins us.


1)Roquan Smith, Georgia

Top end athlete, a true "sideline to sideline player" with fantastic instincts that when paired with his elite movement skill allows him to frequently be around to ball making plays. Probably going to be a little small at the next level and could have problems when unable to be ahead of blockers. More than likely Smith will end up being a borderline pro-bowl player the minute he walks on the field.

2)Tremaine Edwards

It was very difficult placing Edwards on this list. He is one of the biggest, fastest, most flexible athletic players I've ever scouted. Edwards is disruptive in all phases, and has shown the ability to be an effective rusher as well. It will be a process however, as Edwards appears to rely entirely on his athletic ability and has very inconsistent technique. With good coaching, after what I'm thinking will be a very up and down rookie season, if He commits to refining his game, Edwards could be one of the premiere players on the defensive side of the ball league hide.

3)Rashaan Evans

Evans is a long athletic player, that is still learning the finer points of the position. Technique is very inconsistent but has shown great improvement every season while at Alabama. With proper coaching Evans will be a star at the next level

4)Leighton Vander Esch

Vander Esch is an incredibly athletic linebacker who seemed to always be around the ball last season. Quite frankly his 2017 tape is some of the best I've scouted. However, his one year of starting experience gives me pause, and makes me feel that he could face a steep learning curve at the next level

5)Malik Jefferson

Jefferson is a frustrating case as he is prototypical in terms in size, speed, strength etc. but after watching the tape he seems to play very inconsistently when asked to anything besides line up and play. Last season the coaching staff simplified things for him, and he nearly doubled his tackle total as a result. The good news is that there are teams such as the Dallas Cowboys that usually run a scheme similar in the sense that he would be able to play on instincts, Situation will make a huge difference in terms of post draft outlook for Jefferson.

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports
Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports


1. Roquan Smith, Georgia

Smith is the consensus #1 LB in what is shaping up to be a good draft for the position. He has elite athleticism and intangibles. He's involved in just about every single play. At 236, he's not the biggest LB, and can be swallowed by big lineman if they get a hand on him, but he's a good tackler, great in coverage, and has lightning reflexes and instincts. As great as he is, he has yet to tap into his full potential. He'll undoubtedly go top 15, likely top 10.

2. Tremaine Edmunds, Virginia Tech

Like Smith, Edmunds has a lot of potential and great athleticism, but he's about 4 inches taller and 15 pounds heavier. The reason Smith is higher is because Edmunds doesn't have the elite instincts that Smith has. He can be a tad late to the party. An NFL coach should fix that and make him a yearly Pro Bowler.

3. Leighton Vander Esch, Boise State

Now this is a name that has been getting lots of buzz lately. Only started at Boise State for one year, but he certainly opened eyes during that year. Leighton has surprisingly good instincts. He's a guy who will never need to come off the field, he's very good against both the pass and the run.

4. Rashaan Evans, Alabama

And now for the last of the projected 1st round picks, we have the ultra athletic Rashaan Evans. He is a sideline to sideline LB with a nose for the football. Plus instincts, speed, and solid blitzing skills carry him where he needs to go, but don't let his 232 pound body bother you, he's an explosive fundamental tackler. Tackles the way your supposed to tackle while still putting some sting on 'em.

5. Micah Kiser, Virginia

After the 1st 4 guys go, it's really any man's guess as to who goes next. It depends on what type of linebacker you want. If you want a guy who will mentally and physically make a running backs life hell, Kiser is your guy. He has some of the best pursuit skills I've seen in awhile. Whatever hole the running back is supposed to be in, you'll find Kiser running through it. If that lane is filled, he'll find the cutback lane and ruin the backs day with a bang. Kiser has a lot of work to do in pass coverage, and isn't the most athletic, but he'll shut the run down with the best of them.